Jeffrey S. Custer, aged 64, passed away June 23, 2025, after a brief illness. He was born April 14, 1961, in Cleveland, Ohio, to his parents, Beverly J. (Cadmes) and Theodore C. Custer. 

Jeffrey was very devoted to his family and enjoyed listening to music, watching indie films or the news and always loved a good pun, as he had a great sense of humor. He was known as the cookie master and would spend time delivering homemade cookies around town. 

Preceded in death by his parents, Theodore and Beverly and his brother-in-law, Guy Bahrt. He is survived by his loving wife of 39 years, Marilyn, his children: Allison Custer and Jonathan Custer; his siblings: Pamela Bahrt, Theodore Custer, Kenneth (Verla) Custer and Tracey Custer; as well as several nieces, a nephew and many cats.

Memorial Service will be held Saturday, June 28, 2025, at 11:00 a.m. at Trinity United Church of Christ at 215 High Street, Wadsworth, Ohio 44281 with a visitation one hour prior to the service. 

In lieu of flowers, please donate to Trinity United Church of Christ or American Cancer Society.